◀ C. Salomon | ▲ Proceedings | S. Elti di Rodeano ▶ |
ISBN: 978-2-9570549-6-1 e-ISBN: 978-2-9570549-8-5 Download (17.11 MB) | Grammar Drives Writing System Evolution. Lessons From the Birth of Vowels Daniel Harbour Download (271.01 kB) Abstract. Vowel omission is a common trait of Afroasiatic writing systems. The current article places this observation on empirically firm footing by showing that, across a large range of cases, the transmission of alphabetic writing within Afroasiatic shows only minimal increases in vowel writing, in contrast to transmission beyond Afroasiatic, where vowel writing markedly increases. This correlation is analysed as a reflex of grammatical differences between Afroasiatic and non-Afroasiatic languages, connected to the predictability of vowels from grammatical and pragmatic context. Where they are not contextually recoverable, omitted vowels amount, owing to Afroasiatic grammar, to omitted morphemes, a feature of other writing systems, including early Chinese and Sumerian. As a result, both the underrepresentation of vowels within Afroasiatic writing systems and the increase in vowel representation beyond Afroasiatic represent adaptations of writing systems to grammatical niches. Philographic theory must therefore recognise grammar as a driving force in writing system evolution. DOI: https://doi.org/10.36824/2020-graf-harb
@BOOK{adiego:07, AUTHOR = {Ignasi-Xavier Adiego}, TITLE = {The {C}arian Language}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2007}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{adiego:20, AUTHOR = {Ignasi-Xavier Adiego}, EDITOR = {Kim, Ronald I. and Jana Mynářová and Peter Pavúk}, TITLE = {Consonant Clusters, Defective Notation of Vowels and Syllable Structure in {C}aromemphite}, BOOKTITLE = {Hrozný and {H}ittite: {T}he First Hundred Years}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2020}, PAGES = {95--119}, } @BOOK{alster:05, AUTHOR = {Bendt Alster}, TITLE = {Wisdom Of Ancient {S}umer}, PUBLISHER = {Eisenbrauns}, ADDRESS = {University Park, PA}, YEAR = {2005}, } @BOOK{arad:05, AUTHOR = {Maya Arad}, TITLE = {Roots and Patterns: {H}ebrew Morpho-Syntax}, PUBLISHER = {Springer}, ADDRESS = {Dordrecht}, YEAR = {2005}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{banafunzi-vianello:14, AUTHOR = {Bana Banafunzi and Alessandra Vianello}, EDITOR = {Meikal Mumin and Kees Versteegh}, TITLE = {Chimi:ni in {A}rabic Script: {E}xamples from {B}rava Poetry}, BOOKTITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {S}tudies in the Use of a Writing System}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2014}, PAGES = {293--310}, } @BOOK{baxter-sagart:14, AUTHOR = {William Baxter and Laurent Sagart}, TITLE = {Old {C}hinese: {A} New Reconstruction}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford University Press}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {2014}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{bondarev:14, AUTHOR = {Dmitry Bondarev}, EDITOR = {Meikal Mumin and Kees Versteegh}, TITLE = {Old {K}anumbu and {K}anuri in {A}rabic Script: {P}honology through the Graphic System}, BOOKTITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {S}tudies in the Use of a Writing System}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2014}, PAGES = {107--142}, } @ARTICLE{cathcart:11, AUTHOR = {Cathcart, Kevin J.}, TITLE = {The Earliest Contributions to the Decipherment of {S}umerian and {A}kkadian}, JOURNAL = {Cuneiform Digital Library Journal}, YEAR = {2011}, VOLUME = {1}, PAGES = {1--12}, URL = {www.cdli.ucla.edu/pubs/cdlj/2011/cdlj2011\_001.html}, } @BOOK{coulmas:03, AUTHOR = {Florian Coulmas}, TITLE = {Writing Systems: {A}n Introduction to the Linguistic Analysis}, PUBLISHER = {Blackwells}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {2003}, } @MISC{crellin:18, AUTHOR = {Robert Crellin}, TITLE = {Measuring Ambiguity in the {W}est-{S}emitic Abjad}, YEAR = {2018}, NOTE = {Paper presented at the {M}ainz {I}nternational {C}olloquium on {A}ncient {H}ebrew}, } @BOOK{cross-freedman:52, AUTHOR = {Cross, Frank M., Jr. and Freedman, David N.}, TITLE = {Early {H}ebrew Orthography: {A} Study of the Epigraphic Evidence}, PUBLISHER = {American Oriental Society}, ADDRESS = {New Haven, CT}, YEAR = {1952}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{daniels:14, AUTHOR = {Daniels, Peter T.}, EDITOR = {Meikal Mumin and Kees Versteegh}, TITLE = {The Type and Spread of {A}rabic Script}, BOOKTITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {S}tudies in the Use of a Writing System}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2014}, PAGES = {25--39}, } @ARTICLE{darnell:05, AUTHOR = {Darnell, John Coleman and F.~W. Dobbs-Allsopp and Lundberg, Marilyn J. and McCarter, P.~Kyle and Bruce Zuckerman and Colleen Manassa}, TITLE = {Two Early Alphabetic Inscriptions from the {W}adi el-\d{H}\^ol: {N}ew Evidence for the Origin of the Alphabet from the Western Desert of {E}gypt}, JOURNAL = {The Annual of the American Schools of Oriental Research}, YEAR = {2005}, VOLUME = {59}, PAGES = {63--124}, } @ARTICLE{diem:79-83, AUTHOR = {Werner Diem}, TITLE = {Untersuchungen zur fr\"uhen {G}eschichte der arabischen Orthographie, {I--IV}}, JOURNAL = {Orientalia}, YEAR = {1979--1983}, VOLUME = {48}, PAGES = {207--257; 49, 67--106; 51, 332--381; 52,357--383}, } @BOOK{diringer:48, EDITOR = {Diringer, David}, TITLE = {The Alphabet: {A} Key to the History of Mankind}, PUBLISHER = {Thames and Hudson}, ADDRESS = {London}, YEAR = {1948}, } @BOOK{donner-rollig:02, AUTHOR = {Herbert Donner and Wolfgang R\"ollig}, TITLE = {Kanaan\"aische und aram\"aische {I}nschriften}, EDITION = {5}, PUBLISHER = {Harrassowitz}, ADDRESS = {Wiesbaden}, YEAR = {2002}, VOLUME = {1}, } @ARTICLE{dupont-sommer:66, AUTHOR = {Dupont-Sommer, Andr\'e}, TITLE = {Une nouvelle inscription aram\'eenne d'{A}soka d\'ecouverte \`a {K}andahar ({A}fghanistan)}, JOURNAL = {Comptes rendus des s\'eances de l'Acad\'emie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres}, YEAR = {1966}, VOLUME = {110}, PAGES = {440--451}, } @BOOK{frakes:04, EDITOR = {Frakes, Jerold C.}, TITLE = {Early {Y}iddish Texts 1100--1750: {W}ith Introduction and Commentary}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford {U}niversity {P}ress}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {2004}, } @BOOK{frakes:14, EDITOR = {Frakes, Jerold C.}, TITLE = {Early {Y}iddish Epic}, PUBLISHER = {Syracuse University Press}, ADDRESS = {Syracuse, NY}, YEAR = {2014}, } @BOOK{frakes:17, AUTHOR = {Frakes, Jerold C.}, TITLE = {A Guide to {O}ld {L}iterary {Y}iddish}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford {U}niversity {P}ress}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {2017}, } @BOOK{gelb:63, AUTHOR = {Gelb, Ignace Jay}, TITLE = {A Study of Writing}, PUBLISHER = {University of Chicago Press}, ADDRESS = {Chicago, IL}, YEAR = {1963}, } @ARTICLE{gnanadesikan:17, AUTHOR = {Gnanadesikan, Amalia E.}, TITLE = {Towards a typology of phonemic scripts}, JOURNAL = {Writing Systems Research}, YEAR = {2017}, VOLUME = {9}, PAGES = {14--35}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{hary:96, AUTHOR = {Bejamin Hary}, EDITOR = {Peter Daniels and William Bright}, TITLE = {Adaptations of {H}ebrew Script}, BOOKTITLE = {The World's Writing Systems}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford University Press}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {1996}, PAGES = {727--734 and 741--742}, } @ARTICLE{hincks:52, AUTHOR = {Hincks, Edward}, TITLE = {On the {A}ssyrio-{B}abylonian Phonetic Characters}, JOURNAL = {Transactions of the Royal Irish Academy}, YEAR = {1852}, VOLUME = {22}, PAGES = {293--370}, } @BOOK{hincks:63, AUTHOR = {Hincks, Edward}, TITLE = {On the Polyphony of the {A}ssyrio-{B}abylonian Cuneiform Writing: {A} Letter to {P}rofessor {R}enouf}, PUBLISHER = {John F.~Fowler}, ADDRESS = {Dublin}, YEAR = {1863}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{kara:96, AUTHOR = {Kara, Gy\"orgy}, EDITOR = {Peter Daniels and William Bright}, TITLE = {Aramaic Scripts for {A}ltaic Languages}, BOOKTITLE = {The World's Writing Systems}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford University Press}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {1996}, PAGES = {537--558}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{kaye:96, AUTHOR = {Kaye, Alan S.}, EDITOR = {Peter Daniels and William Bright}, TITLE = {Adaptations of {A}rabic Script}, BOOKTITLE = {The World's Writing Systems}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford University Press}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {1996}, PAGES = {743--762}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{luffin:14, AUTHOR = {Xavier Luffin}, EDITOR = {Meikal Mumin and Kees Versteegh}, TITLE = {Swahili Documents from {C}ongo (19th Century): {V}ariation in Orthography}, BOOKTITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {S}tudies in the Use of a Writing System}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2014}, PAGES = {311--318}, } @ARTICLE{martin:19, AUTHOR = {Martin, Alexander and Theeraporn Ratitamkul and Klaus Abels and David Adger and Jennifer Culbertson}, TITLE = {Cross-linguistic Evidence for Cognitive Universals in the Noun Phrase}, JOURNAL = {Linguistics Vanguard}, YEAR = {2019}, PAGES = {PsyArXiv doi:10.31234/osf.io/jnqug}, } @ARTICLE{martinez:74, AUTHOR = {Mart\'inez Ruiz, Juan}, TITLE = {Un nuevo texto aljamiado: el recetario de sahumerios en uno de los manuscritos \'arabes de {O}ca\~na}, JOURNAL = {Revista de dialectologia y tradiciones populares}, YEAR = {1974}, VOLUME = {30}, PAGES = {3--37}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{meyer:16, AUTHOR = {Meyer, Ronny}, EDITOR = {Binyam Sisay Mendisu and Janne Bondi Johannessen}, TITLE = {The {E}thiopic Script: {L}inguistic Features and Socio-Cultural Connotations}, BOOKTITLE = {Multilingual {E}thiopia: {L}inguistic Challenges and Capacity Building Efforts}, PUBLISHER = {University of Oslo}, ADDRESS = {Oslo}, YEAR = {2016}, PAGES = {137--172}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{mumin:14, AUTHOR = {Mumin, Meikal}, EDITOR = {Meikal Mumin and Kees Versteegh}, TITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {U}nderstudied Literacy}, BOOKTITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {S}tudies in the Use of a Writing System}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2014}, PAGES = {41--76}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{oconnorx:96, AUTHOR = {O'Connor, Michael}, EDITOR = {Peter Daniels and William Bright}, TITLE = {Epigraphic {S}emitic Scripts}, BOOKTITLE = {The World's Writing Systems}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford University Press}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {1996}, PAGES = {88--107, 116--118}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{oconnor:96, AUTHOR = {O'Connor, Michael}, EDITOR = {Peter Daniels and William Bright}, TITLE = {The {B}erber Scripts}, BOOKTITLE = {The World's Writing Systems}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford University Press}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {1996}, PAGES = {112--116, 119}, } @BOOK{pountain:00, AUTHOR = {Pountain, Christopher J.}, TITLE = {A History of the {S}panish Language through Texts}, PUBLISHER = {Routledge}, ADDRESS = {London and New York}, YEAR = {2000}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{riesenberg-kaneshiro:60, AUTHOR = {Riesenberg, Saul H. and Shigeru Kaneshiro}, TITLE = {A {C}aroline {I}slands Script}, BOOKTITLE = {Bureau of American Ethnology Bulletin 173}, PUBLISHER = {Smithsonian Institution}, ADDRESS = {Washington DC}, YEAR = {1960}, PAGES = {269--333}, } @BOOK{sacks:14, AUTHOR = {Jonathan Sacks}, TITLE = {The Great Partnership: {S}cience, Religion, and the Search for Meaning}, PUBLISHER = {Schocken Books}, ADDRESS = {New York, NY}, YEAR = {2014}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{salomon:96, AUTHOR = {Salomon, Richard G.}, EDITOR = {Peter Daniels and William Bright}, TITLE = {Brahmi and {K}harosthi}, BOOKTITLE = {The World's Writing Systems}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford University Press}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {1996}, PAGES = {373--383}, } @BOOK{sampson:15, AUTHOR = {Sampson, Geoffrey}, TITLE = {Writing Systems: {A} Linguistic Introduction}, PUBLISHER = {Equinox}, ADDRESS = {London}, YEAR = {2015}, NOTE = {Second edition (first edition 1985, Stanford University Press)}, } @BOOK{sass:05, AUTHOR = {Benjamin Sass}, TITLE = {The Alphabet at the Turn of the Millennium: {T}he {W}est {S}emitic Alphabet ca.\ 1150--850 \textsc{bce}; {T}he Antiquity of the {A}rabian, {G}reek and {P}hrygian Alphabets}, PUBLISHER = {Tel Aviv University Institute of Archaeology}, ADDRESS = {Tel Aviv}, YEAR = {2005}, } @ARTICLE{schmitz:95, AUTHOR = {Schmitz, Philip C.}, TITLE = {The {P}hoenician Text from the {E}truscan Sanctuary at {P}yrgi}, JOURNAL = {Journal of the American Oriental Society}, YEAR = {1995}, VOLUME = {115}, PAGES = {559--575}, } @BOOK{schniedewind-hunt:07, AUTHOR = {Schniedewind, William M. and Hunt, Joel H.}, TITLE = {A Primer on {U}garitic: {L}anguage, Culture and Literature}, PUBLISHER = {Cambridge {U}niversity {P}ress}, ADDRESS = {Cambridge}, YEAR = {2007}, } @ARTICLE{share:14, AUTHOR = {Share, David L.}, TITLE = {Alphabetism in Reading Science}, JOURNAL = {Frontiers in Psychology}, YEAR = {2014}, VOLUME = {5}, PAGES = {752}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{skjaervo:96, AUTHOR = {Skj{\ae}rv{\o}, P.~Oktor}, EDITOR = {Peter Daniels and William Bright}, TITLE = {Aramaic Scripts for {I}ranian Languages}, BOOKTITLE = {The World's Writing Systems}, PUBLISHER = {Oxford University Press}, ADDRESS = {Oxford}, YEAR = {1996}, PAGES = {515--535}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{souag:14, AUTHOR = {Lameen Souag}, EDITOR = {Meikal Mumin and Kees Versteegh}, TITLE = {Writing `{S}helha' in New Media: {E}mergent non-{A}rabic Literacy in Southwestern {A}lgeria}, BOOKTITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {S}tudies in the Use of a Writing System}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2014}, PAGES = {91--104}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{souag:19, AUTHOR = {Lameen Souag}, EDITOR = {Dmitry Bondarev and Alessandro Gori and Lameen Souag}, TITLE = {Kabyle in {A}rabic Script: {A} History without Standardisation}, BOOKTITLE = {Creating Standards: {I}nteractions with {A}rabic Script in 12 Manuscript Cultures}, PUBLISHER = {De Gruyter}, ADDRESS = {Berlin, Boston}, YEAR = {2019}, PAGES = {273--296}, URL = {doi.org/10.1515/9783110639063-011}, } @BOOK{taylor:83, AUTHOR = {Isaac Taylor}, TITLE = {The Alphabet: {A}n Account of the Origin and Development of Letters}, PUBLISHER = {Kegan Paul, Trench}, ADDRESS = {London}, YEAR = {1883}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{vydrin:14, AUTHOR = {Valentin Vydrin}, EDITOR = {Meikal Mumin and Kees Versteegh}, TITLE = {Ajami Scripts for {M}ande Languages}, BOOKTITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {S}tudies in the Use of a Writing System}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2014}, PAGES = {199--224}, } @INPROCEEDINGS{vydrin-dumestre:14, AUTHOR = {Valentin Vydrin and G\'erard Dumestre}, EDITOR = {Meikal Mumin and Kees Versteegh}, TITLE = {Manding Ajami Samples: {M}andinka and {B}amana}, BOOKTITLE = {The {A}rabic Script in {A}frica: {S}tudies in the Use of a Writing System}, PUBLISHER = {Brill}, ADDRESS = {Leiden}, YEAR = {2014}, PAGES = {225--260}, } Daniel Harbour (2020), “Grammar Drives Writing System Evolution. Lessons From the Birth of Vowels,” in Proceedings of Grapholinguistics in the 21st Century, 2020 (Yannis Haralambous, Ed.), Grapholinguistics and Its Applications, Vol. 4, Brest: Fluxus Editions, 201–221.
@INPROCEEDINGS{gla4-harb, AUTHOR = {Daniel Harbour}, EDITOR = {Haralambous, Yannis}, TITLE = {{Grammar Drives Writing System Evolution. Lessons From the Birth of Vowels}}, BOOKTITLE = {{Proceedings of Grapholinguistics in the 21st Century, 2020}}, SERIES = {{Grapholinguistics and Its Applications}}, VOLUME = {4}, PUBLISHER = {Fluxus Editions}, ADDRESS = {Brest}, YEAR = {2020}, PAGES = {201--221}, DOI = {https://doi.org/10.36824/2020-graf-harb}, } |